If you are in an emergency, in crisis or need someone to talk to, there is help.

View Crisis Resouces
Skip to content
  • Contact Us
  • No One Left Behind
  • Join our team
  • Referral Form
  • Virtual Urgent Care
  • Accessibility
CAMH logo
  • Patients and Families
    • Main Page
    • Access CAMH & Referral Form
      • Access CAMH

        Centralized information, intake and scheduling. Access CAMH makes it easy to find support – simply call 416-535-8501, option 2.

      • Referral Form

        For mental health services, a referral form needs to be completed by a healthcare provider. For addictions services, patient can self-refer.

    • Programs & Services
      • Addictions/Substance Use
      • Alzheimer’s & Dementia
      • Anxiety & Depression
      • Concurrent Disorders
      • Developmental Disabilities
      • Mood & Personality Disorders
      • Problem Gambling
      • Schizophrenia & Psychosis
      • Trauma & Stress Disorders
      • Virtual Mental Health and Outreach
      • Other
    • Information for Patients
      • Patient Wellness and Patient Engagement at CAMH
      • What to expect
      • Your Rights
      • Patient and Family Feedback
      • Visiting CAMH

        Planning on visiting CAMH? Find contact information, directions and accessibility for each of our three main sites.

    • Information for Families
      • Family Resource Centre
      • Patient and Family Feedback
      • Visiting CAMH

        Planning on visiting CAMH? Find contact information, directions and accessibility for each of our three main sites.

    • Patient and Family Engagement
      • Patient and Family Partners Program
      • Information and resources
      • Get Involved in Research
      • Volunteer at CAMH
    • Visiting CAMH
      • Visiting CAMH

        Planning on visiting CAMH? Find contact information, directions and accessibility for each of our three main sites.

        Read More
    • MyCAMH
  • Health Info
    • Main Page
    • Mental Illness & Addiction Index
      • Conditions & Disorders
      • Medication Therapies
      • Substance Use
      • Types of Treatment
      • Information in Other Languages
    • Mental Health 101
      • Mental Health 101

        Use this series of free online tutorials as the starting point to learn about and understand a wide range of mental health topics.

        Read More
    • Guides & Publications
      • Guides & Publications

        Accessible, reliable, professionally produced resources on an array of mental health topics for patients, families, students and professionals.

        Read More
    • Crisis Resources
      • Crisis Resources

        If you are in an emergency, in crisis or need someone to talk to, there is a list of resources available for areas in and around Toronto.

        Read More
    • CAMH Store
      • CAMH Store

        The CAMH Store offers a wide array of mental illness and addiction resources for patients, families, students and professionals. Search or browse our catalogue of brochures and booklets, textbooks, manuals and assessment tools.

        Read More
    • CAMH Library
      • CAMH Library

        Open to professionals and the general public, our comprehensive resources and services support and enhance CAMH's research and clinical programs, and they facilitate learning, dynamic knowledge exchange and health promotion initiatives.

        Read More
    • Workplace Mental Health Playbook
    • Mental Health and the COVID-19 Pandemic
      • Coping with stress & anxiety
      • Quarantine & isolation
      • Stigma and prejudice
      • Loss, grief and healing
      • Resources for Health Care Workers
  • Research
    • Main Page
    • Research Areas at CAMH
      • Brain Science

        CAMH is revolutionizing our understanding of the brain and the causes, biomarkers and treatments of mental illness.

      • Personalized Care

        By understanding diverse groups, we prevent, diagnose and care for each one with greater precision and personalization.

      • Prevention and Policy

        Using evidence, we drive system and social change to optimize care and reduce the burden of mental illness, including addictions, across populations.

    • The Discovery Fund
      • The Discovery Fund

        Fuelling the next generation of groundbreaking research and innovation dedicated to finding the causes of and cures for mental illness.

        Read More
    • Institutes & Centres
      • Azrieli Adult Neurodevelopmental Centre
      • Azrieli Centre for Neuro-Radiochemistry
      • Brain Health Imaging Centre
      • Campbell Family Mental Health Research Institute
      • Centre for Youth Bipolar Disorder
      • Cundill Centre for Child and Youth Depression
      • Institute for Mental Health Policy Research
      • Krembil Centre for Neuroinformatics
      • Slaight Family Centre for Youth in Transition
      • Tanenbaum Centre for Pharmacogenetics
      • Temerty Centre for Therapeutic Brain Intervention
      • The Margaret and Wallace McCain Centre for Child Youth & Family Mental Health
    • Clinical Divisions
      • Addictions Division
      • Adult Neurodevelopmental and Geriatric Psychiatry Division
      • Child and Youth Psychiatry Division
      • Forensic Psychiatry Division
      • General and Health Systems Psychiatry Division
      • Psychology Division
      • Schizophrenia Division
    • Research Discoveries
      • Research Discoveries

        At the leading edge of breakthrough mental health and addiction research for over 50 years.

      • BrainBuzz Newsletter

        The latest news, groundbreaking discoveries and special features about CAMH research, studies, and the people behind the work.

      • Research Strategic Plan

        Learn what drives our research agenda and priorities in the CAMH Research Plan for 2018-2023

    • Research Connect
      • Research Connect FAQs
      • Research Ethics
    • Koerner Centre for Research Training
      • Koerner Centre for Research Training

        Each year CAMH provides opportunities to the next generation of scientists: today’s undergraduate students, graduate students and postdoctoral researchers. Train in a unique learning environment and help contribute to the breakthrough mental health research and treatments of tomorrow

        Read More
    • Science & Research Staff Directory
      • Our Scientific Staff
      • Research Chairs at CAMH
    • Industry Partnerships & Technology Transfer Office (IPTTO)
  • Education
    • Main Page
    • Continuing Education Programs and Courses
      • Find the Course That's Right for You

        Browse our entire selection of certificate programs, webinars and workshops.

      • Workplace Education and Consulting Services

        View our full list of workplace mental health workshops and consulting services

    • Collaborative Learning College
    • Simulation Centre
    • TIDES
    • Student Centre
    • Clinical & Research Opportunities for Professionals in Training
      • Clinical Psychology Training Programs
      • Community-Based Research Fellowship
      • Graduate & Post-Doctoral Fellowships in Public Health Policy
      • Clinical & Research Opportunities for Professionals in Training

        Study in a world-class setting to become a leader in the field of mental health.

    • Research in Education
      • Academic & Education Research Excellence
      • Health Equity and Inclusion Framework for Education and Training
    • Evaluation
    • Workplace Mental Health Workshops and Consulting
    • CAMH Education Contacts
  • Professionals
    • Main Page
    • Treating Conditions & Disorders
      • NAVIGATE - Treating Psychosis in Youth
      • CARIBOU - Treating depression in youth
      • Virtual Mental Health
      • Alcohol Use
      • Anxiety Disorders
      • Dementia
      • Depression
      • Suicide Risk
      • Fundamentals of Addiction
      • Intellectual & Developmental Disabilities
      • Mania
      • OCD
      • Opioid use and opioid use disorder
      • Perinatal Mood & Anxiety Disorders
      • Personality Disorders
      • Psychosis
      • Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
      • Smoking Cessation
    • Professionals Projects
      • Climate Change and Mental Health
      • Health Care Access Research and Developmental Disabilities
      • Immigrant and Refugee Mental Health Project
      • Opioid Use in Primary Care Conference 2024
    • Networks
      • Psychiatry Partnerships with Northern Communities
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Get Involved
    • Main Page
    • Ways to Donate
      • Give Monthly
      • Give In Memory or In Honour
      • Start a Fundraiser
      • Gifts of Celebration
      • Leave a Gift in Your Will
      • Employee Giving
      • Donate Goods & Services
      • Gifts of Securities
      • Canvassers & Callers
      • Make a one-time donation

        With your support, CAMH researchers are revolutionizing the ways we diagnose, treat, and prevent mental illness. Donate today.

    • Join the Cause
      • Corporate Partnerships
      • Business Leaders for Mental Health
      • CAMH Engage
      • womenmind
      • Visionary Society
      • Michael Wilson Society
      • Volunteer at CAMH
    • Making a Real Impact
      • Making a Real Impact

        Real stories of courage, hope and discovery. Made possible through your continued support of CAMH.

        Read More
  • Driving Change
    • Main Page
    • About CAMH
      • Leadership Team Directory
      • Performance & Accountability
      • The Role of CAMH Foundation
      • For Reporters
      • Events Calendar
      • For Our Neighbours
      • Contact CAMH
      • Careers at CAMH

        By working at CAMH, you can help people affected by mental illness and support their recovery. Join the team. Everyone who works at CAMH becomes an advocate for mental health.

    • The Crisis is Real
      • The Crisis is Real

        We are in the grips of a crisis that ruins health, threatens lives and hurts economies. Knowing the facts is the first step in creating hope.

      • Mental Health Statistics

        The latest facts and statistics on mental illness and addiction, who's affected and their impact on Canadians.

    • Addressing Stigma
      • Addressing Stigma

        Challenging the stigma associated with mental illness takes understanding, education and a closer look at our own attitudes toward health.

        Read More
    • The Mental Health Facility of the Future
      • The Mental Health Facility of the Future

        Turning what was once a walled institution into a symbol of hope for the future of mental health care.

      • Vision & Guiding Principles

        How do you replace an institution with an urban village? Lots of planning, imagination and a long-term commitment to serving patients, staff and the community.

      • History of Queen Street Site

        Our history—evolving from an asylum into a modern health facility with patients at the centre of care—is the history of mental health care in Canada.

    • Influencing Public Policy
      • Influencing Public Policy

        CAMH advocates for policies that are responsive to the needs of people with mental illness and addictions.

        Read More
    • Health Equity
      • Health Equity

        CAMH believes in the principle of equity. We respect the diversity of the individuals and communities we serve.

        Read More
    • Shkaabe Makwa
    • CAMH News & Stories
    • Strategic Plan
    • Contact Us
    • No One Left Behind
    • Join our team
    • Referral Form
    • Virtual Urgent Care
    • Accessibility

Personality Disorders: Diagnosis

CAMH Logo
  • Personality Disorders: Diagnosis
Back to top
  • Home
  • Professionals
  • Treating Conditions & Disorders
  • Personality Disorders
  • Diagnosis
CAMH logo
  • Personality Disorders
  • Screening
  • Diagnosis
  • Treatment
  • Resources & References
Back to top

Text adapted from: "The adult patient with a personality disorder," in Psychiatry in primary care   by Michael Rosenbluth, Matthew Boyle & Lucille Schiffman (CAMH, 2019).

Specific Personality Disorders

Of the 10 personality disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5; American Psychiatric Association, 2013 ), varying degrees of research exist to support their diagnosis. Underlying all of the personality disorders is a deep-seated maladaptive style that is part of the person’s personality. This maladaptive style is pervasive and longstanding, from the teenage years onward.

The most commonly diagnosed personality disorders are borderline personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder. Another personality disorder that primary care practitioners sometimes find difficult to diagnose and treat is narcissistic personality disorder.

 
Borderline personality disorder

Diagnosing BPD requires that the patient fulfil five out of nine DSM-5 criteria. This means that two people with BPD can have markedly different symptoms and presentations. The mnemonic IMPULSIVE is a helpful way to remember BPD criteria:

  • Impulsiveness in two potentially damaging areas (e.g., sex, substance use, shopping)
  • Mood instability due to marked reactivity
  • Paranoia or dissociation under stress
  • Unstable self-image
  • Labile intense relationships
  • Suicidal gestures
  • Inappropriate anger
  • Vulnerability to abandonment, frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment
  • Emptiness, chronic feelings of emptiness.
Narcissistic personality disorder

Narcissistic personality disorder features a pervasive pattern of grandiosity, a need for admiration and a lack of empathy beginning in early adulthood and presenting in various contexts.

The diagnosis requires meeting five of the following nine DSM-5 criteria:

  • grandiose sense of self-importance
  • preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power and brilliance
  • belief that one is special and unique and can only be understood by or associate with other special or high-status people
  • need for excessive admiration
  • sense of entitlement
  • interpersonally exploitive behaviour (i.e., taking advantage of others to achieve one’s ends)
  • lack of empathy
  • envy of others or the belief that others are envious of the person
  • arrogant, haughty behaviours or attitudes.

Diagnostic changes in DSM-5

Transition-age youth

According to DSM-5, features of a personality disorder usually begin to manifest during adolescence and early adulthood. In earlier versions of DSM, a personality disorder could not be diagnosed in someone under age 18; however, DSM-5 now allows this diagnosis if the features have been present for at least one year. This change has important implications for treatment. For example, recent research indicates that BPD can be a reliable diagnosis in youth, providing an opportunity to intervene early to improve prognosis (Kaess et al., 2014). The one diagnosis that cannot be made for people under age 18 is antisocial personality disorder.

Axis I and Axis II disorders

With the release of DSM-5 came a major change in how personality disorders are considered in a diagnostic assessment. The previous manual, DSM-IV, featured a system that separated diagnoses into five “axes.” Most of the major psychiatric disorders were classified as Axis I disorders. They included:

  • major depressive disorder
  • bipolar affective disorder
  • schizophrenia
  • generalized anxiety disorder
  • panic disorder
  • posttraumatic stress disorder
  • obsessive compulsive disorder
  • substance use disorders.

Axis II included the 10 personality disorders and intellectual disability. The multiaxial system was introduced partly because certain disorders, such as personality disorders, received inadequate clinical and research focus, and giving them a separate designation would ensure they received more attention. When DSM-5 was being compiled, it was determined that this situation had changed, so the multiaxial system was no longer needed. DSM-5 retains all 10 personality disorders, with only slight changes to wording in the diagnostic criteria (APA, 2013).

Although Axis I and II no longer exist in DSM-5, this chapter still uses these terms because they are conceptually helpful when discussing diagnosis and treatment of personality disorders.

Diagnostic issues

Making the Axis I diagnosis with a co-occurring personality disorder

Patients with personality disorders often have co-occurring Axis I diagnoses. This is particularly common in BPD. One study found that 96 percent of patients with BPD will have a lifetime Axis I comorbidity with mood disorders: 9 percent with bipolar disorder; 88 percent with anxiety disorders; 55 percent with post traumatic stress disorder; 53 percent with eating disorders; and 64 percent with substance use disorders (Zanarini et al., 1998).

Given this high comorbidity, the challenge is not only to identify and optimally manage the personality disorder, but also to not overlook comorbid Axis I diagnoses. Primary care practitioners may find the Axis I diagnoses easier to deal with; however, patients with both Axis I and Axis II disorders need treatment plans that address both.

Challenges in Identifying Co-occurring Axis I Disorders 

Clinicians, including primary care practitioners, often overlook the comorbid Axis I diagnoses. The typically chaotic presentation of patients with personality disorder—and clinicians’ reactions to them—make it difficult to assess and diagnose an Axis I disorder. The frustration that some clinicians experience may preclude careful review of the patient’s longitudinal history that would clarify the Axis I diagnosis. Clinicians may feel frustrated by a patient who is disruptive in the waiting room, threatens self-harm or has a history of emotional reactivity, responding to slights with self-harm and impulsive behaviours. Overlooking such a diagnosis means that the patient may not receive appropriate treatment for the Axis I condition.

Distinguishing Between a Personality Disorder and an Axis I Disorder 

One strategy for clarifying the presence of a personality disorder versus an Axis I diagnosis is to review whether the patient has a longstanding history of negative maladaptive behaviours, or whether these behaviours are restricted to when the Axis I diagnosis began.

Some patients may look personality disordered when they are dealing with characteristic stressors that are difficult for them. For example, when people are depressed, it can bring out the worst in their personality. They may appear to have a personality disorder as they become more demanding, inappropriately persistent, emotionally reactive and irritable. However, if the patient’s history or the people in the patient’s support system indicate that the maladaptive behaviours are limited to a response to the difficult stressors, then it is not a personality disorder. If the onset of personality difficulties is recent, you must consider whether an Axis I diagnosis may be the correct diagnosis because these conditions can cause patients to appear to have a personality disorder.

Remember that our clinical assessments tend to be cross-sectional, whereas personality disorders require a longitudinal review of functioning. It is best to defer a personality assessment until the acute Axis I disorder has been successfully treated.

Ask patients to describe their personality prior to their depression. Get a collateral history from family members or significant others who can confirm whether the maladaptive behaviours occur exclusively in the context of an Axis I diagnostic state, or whether they are long-standing from childhood.

Keep in mind that no matter how suggestive the presentation, the diagnosis is unlikely to be a personality disorder if there is no supportive evidence from earlier in life.


In Personality Disorders

  • The Primary Care Practitioner Role
  • Screening & Assessment
  • Diagnosis
  • Treatment 
    • Treatment When There is an Axis-1 Disorder
    • Psychotherapy
    • Coordinating care
    • Managing reactions to the patient
    • Self-harm and suicide
  • Resources & References

Related

  • Psychiatry in Primary Care: A Concise Canadian Pocket Guide 2019

    Read More

  • Borderline Personality Disorder: Resources for Your Patients

    Read More

  • Borderline personality disorder: An information guide for families

    Read More

  • Cognitive Behavioural Therapy: An information guide for families

    Read More

Screening & Assessment
Treatment

Follow us
  • Patient and Family Care
  • Health Info
  • Science and Research
  • Education
  • Professionals
  • Get Involved
  • Driving Change
  • About CAMH
  • Job Openings
  • Purchase Publications
  • Referral Form
  • For Reporters
  • Donor Services
  • Events

CAMH Switchboard

From the GTA: 416 535-8501


Toll-free: 1 800 463-2338

To Access CAMH Clinical Services

416 535-8501, press 2

We have multiple locations. Find directions.

Map of CAMH's Queen Street Site
  • Staff Tools

Copyright 2025 CAMH

  • Terms of Use
  • Accessibility
  • Site Map

Keep in touch with CAMH

Keep your finger on our pulse – latest CAMH news, discoveries and ways to get involved delivered to your inbox.

Please select a newsletter

Please complete the following:

    Required Fields

    Please select a newsletter option

    Please input a first name

    Please input a last name

    Please input an email address

    By clicking Sign Up below, I consent to receive electronic communications (as selected above) from CAMH and CAMH Foundation. To unsubscribe at any time click the link in our mailing or email: unsubscribe@camh.ca

    Please agree to the Terms of Use

     

    Thanks for Subscribing.

    We look forward to keeping you informed, inspired and involved in all things CAMH.

    Double your impact this Mental Health Week

    Your gift to CAMH will now go twice as far to help change mental health care forever.

    $
    Other Ways to Give